![[-]](https://theultimatetone.com/images/collapse.png "[-]")
03-06-2024, 12:19 PM
Hi Guys
The proof is in the execution.
Yes, the jacks are the same basic shape, but the wafer material, thickness of the metal and metal finish can be different and one will last longer than the other. It takes the same time and effort to install either, but which one will need replacing or need its spring contacts retensioned first?
Frankly, many of Switchcraft's products are not that great because of the finish they choose. This is especially problematic on their switches - ironic since that is part of their name and should be what they are really good at
Left on the shelf or in a bin exposed to air the terminals corrode and look quite ugly. They need thorough sanding before you can solder to them. The 1/4" jacks seem to have a better plating and have a long shelf life.
One of the reviews of the stereo form of the linked Aliexpress jack said that the ring contact was poorly aligned and had to be reshaped. There can be a problem sometimes if metric/inch dimensions are used that are not exactly equivalent.
So, you just have to take a chance and get the jacks in hand and maybe try them in your amp to know if they work okay and for how long.
Have fun
The proof is in the execution.
Yes, the jacks are the same basic shape, but the wafer material, thickness of the metal and metal finish can be different and one will last longer than the other. It takes the same time and effort to install either, but which one will need replacing or need its spring contacts retensioned first?
Frankly, many of Switchcraft's products are not that great because of the finish they choose. This is especially problematic on their switches - ironic since that is part of their name and should be what they are really good at
Left on the shelf or in a bin exposed to air the terminals corrode and look quite ugly. They need thorough sanding before you can solder to them. The 1/4" jacks seem to have a better plating and have a long shelf life.One of the reviews of the stereo form of the linked Aliexpress jack said that the ring contact was poorly aligned and had to be reshaped. There can be a problem sometimes if metric/inch dimensions are used that are not exactly equivalent.
So, you just have to take a chance and get the jacks in hand and maybe try them in your amp to know if they work okay and for how long.
Have fun
